» A Culture that Engages Every Family, Steven M. Constantino, Ed.D.
» How Do You Know if You're Really Open to Partnership, Anne Henderson & Karen Mapp
» The Power of Asking-Instead of Telling, Jody McVittie, M.D.
» Empathy in Action, Rick Ackerly, Ed.M.
Most of us have days when discipline "works" - when we show up as the adult that we want to be while still setting appropriate limits. There are other days though (when we are stressed), when we can hear our own parents' or teachers' voices (when they were stressed) coming out of our mouths. That is when we wonder, "What is it with this child?" or hear those internal voices criticizing our own ability to parent, teach or even be a reasonable human being. Those are not the "grown-up moments" that we look forward to. And we all have them.
We also have a pretty good idea about what gets us in these situations. It is that feeling of being "trapped" or having our "buttons" pushed; of not having any good options. It is as if, in the stress of the moment, we open our discipline "toolbox" and the only tools in there are the ones someone else used when they were desperate: the ones we never liked as kids and swore we would never use.
Before "re-stocking" the toolbox, it is helpful to think about what children need to thrive. Children need a sense of belonging (connection) and significance (meaning) in their world. They need an opportunity to explore, take risks and mess things up (freedom) as well as clear limits (order).
The good news is that there are lots of simple, respectful (to both the child and adult) tools that are effective in the long term. By using kindness and firmness at the same time we can discipline (teach) young people the life skills they need without being either permissive or punitive. We build long term relationships. By filling the "toolbox" with more resources you will find that those "old" tools gradually rust at the bottom of the box. Here are some tools that come from discipline principles that work:
Children need a sense of belonging (connection) and significance (meaning). Creating opportunities to connect and contribute will limit misbehavior.
Maintain dignity and respect for yourself and for the situation and child.
Children learn by watching.
Life has ups and downs. Children learn resilience by practicing.
Mistakes are opportunities to learn. Yours and theirs.
Enjoy the child!
A word of caution. Refill your toolbox slowly. It might be that you choose to make a special effort to connect with or listen to this child today. Or perhaps for one week you'll practice staying calm. Gradually, with practice you won't be reaching for those "old" discipline tools nearly as often. You'll understand that it is possible to discipline (teach) our children with kindness and firmness without being either permissive or punitive: from the heart instead of the hip.
Photo credits:Morgan Childers; Natesh Ramasamy;
Posted on June 2, 2012 by Jody McVittie, MD
Jody McVittie has been working with families since she got frustrated with her own family at the ripe age of 3. Needless to say her skills have improved a little since then. She is now a much in demand speaker to help families and schools deal with the kind of know-it-all demanding 3 (and 13) year-olds she once was. She is the executive director of Sound Discipline, a 501 c 3 non-profit dedicated breaking the cycle of family violence by teaching people to do the right thing, even when no one is looking.
Additional Information about our Bloggers
(www.ParentInvolvementMatters.org does not handle reprint requests. For permission to reprint articles, please contact the author directly.)
Tags: *Parent Engagement at Home , Character Development, Parents as teachers, Positive Discipline, Social Skills
Posted July 14, 2012 by Jody McVittie
Erika, I hope you continue to practice. Your children are lucky to have a mom who is eager to keep learning. My word of caution would be to take things one at a time. When we try to do too much we get overwhelmed and discouraged. Best wishes!
Posted July 12, 2012 by Erica McCray
I love these post! I have a five year old and a three year old and my three year old boy is very defiant but lately I noticed he is also insecure. While reading this I do a lot of the wrong things I do sound like every other parent that gets onto there kids I do time outs and always asking the why questions. There in bed now while I am reading this. Now I can't wait to use these tools tommorrow and am looking foward to seeing my children thrive. I now have a better understanding on what they could be thinking. And how to relate and have them know mommy does love them. I do nag a lot mostly over safety issues or them fighting so this I am confident will help us all to better to understand each other. Thanks so much. I want my children to be happy and well rounded so I'm glad I found this.
Posted June 2, 2012 by Jody McVittie
Rick, Thanks for the question. I mostly agree with you. "Why?" questions invite the child to be on the defensive. He or she doesn't know why. You build relationships better with "what" and "how" questions which engage with curiosity and feel more respectful to the child. Having said that, a "why" question can be useful if it comes from a place of genuine curiosity and seeks mutual exploration and discovery - it just isn't how most of us use them.
Posted June 2, 2012 by rick ackerly
Great tool box! I was happy to see that tools with the word "Why" in them have been left out (I choose to see them on the trash heap rather than rusted at the bottom. A rusty tool--either polish and sharpen it, or put it in someone else's garage sale.
OR did a miss some "Why" tool.
|*Parent Engagement at Home (60)|
|Learning environment (27)|
|Critical Thinking (12)|
|Study Skills (6)|
|Social Skills (7)|
|Character Development (22)|
|Bullying Prevention (9)|
|Positive Discipline (13)|
|Parents as teachers (35)|
|*School-Family Partnership (43)|
|Building trust & respect (30)|
|2-way communication (28)|
|Parents in classroom (5)|
|*Diverse Families (10)|
|Low-income/ At risk (3)|
|Special Needs/LD (3)|
|*Technology & Partnership (6)|
|EdTech Resources (1)|
|Social Media (13)|
|*Out-of-School Time (2)|
|*Educational Policy (10)|
|PTA - PTO (7)|
|Ed Reform (11)|
|Mom Congress (1)|
|Education in Norway�Among World's Best|
|This Week's #PTChat: Tips for Parents with Dr. Michele Borba|
|Four Strategies for Helping Gifted Kids Transition Back to School|
|This Week's #PTChat: Make this Year's Back to School Night Your Best Yet!|
|Constructive Parent Involvement on the First Day of School: Five Disciplines for Parental Anxiety|